Workers' Compensation That Protects Your People

Workers’ compensation costs can be among the most complicated and expensive parts of doing business. We’ve worked with over 16,000 employers on all of their workers’ compensation needs since 1963 and we’re honored for the opportunity to do the same for you.

Get a Quote

Take Control of Your Workers' Compensation Costs

Workers' compensation claims can drive up premiums, increase administrative burdens, and impact your bottom line long after an injury occurs.

Sheakley helps Ohio employers reduce workers’ compensation costs through proactive claims management, BWC expertise, transitional light duty programs, and proven cost-containment strategies. Our team works alongside you to improve claim outcomes, control costs, and support a safer, more productive workforce.

Ohio-BWC_Safety-Intervention-Grant-Program

Talk to a Specialist

Why It Matters Now

What Claims Actually Cost Ohio Employers

$93,105

Average cost of a lost-time workers’ compensation claim involving a motor-vehicle crash*

$57,314

Average cost of a lost-time workers’ compensation claim involving a fall or slip*

*Source: National Safety Council Injury Facts, based on NCCI workers’ compensation data for 2023–2024.

How We Help

Everything Your Workers' Comp Program Needs, In One Place

Claims Management

Professional guidance on factors like claim investigations, wage continuation, return-to-work options, vocational rehab, and more.

Hearing Representation

Access to a committed team, who attend Industrial Commission hearings throughout the state.

Settlements

A dedicated team of professionals to assist employers with the settlement of claims.

Disability Relief

Access to a dedicated team of experts who will review all eligible claims for potential disability relief, formerly known as handicap reimbursements, due to a pre-existing condition.

Underwriting & Rating Issues

Analyze eligibility and opportunities under Ohio BWC programs, including Group Experience Rating, Group Retrospective Rating, the Claim Impact Reduction Program, the Substance Use Prevention and Recovery Program, Safety Council programs, and other available rating and incentive options.

$15,000 Medical Only Administration

Review and re-price medical bills to the BWC fee schedule, supply vouchers for each medical bill, and provide an annual financial analysis with customized reports

Continued Education

Provide ongoing advice and recommendations based on any BWC updates and new programs that are instituted.

Non-At-Fault Motor Vehicle Accidents & Subrogation

Access to a dedicated experienced team to review all eligible claims for potential subrogation or Non-At-Fault (NAF) Motor Vehicle Accident Benefit.

How We Support Self-Insured Employers

Is Self-Insurance Right for Your Organization?

For qualifying employers, self-insurance can provide greater control over claims administration, cost-containment strategies, and return-to-work outcomes. Sheakley’s experienced self-insured claims professionals work as an extension of your team to reduce claim costs, ensure regulatory compliance, and deliver exceptional service to injured workers.

Schedule a Complimentary Consultation and Program Review

No obligation. We’ll review your current program and help determine if self-insurance is the right fit for your organization.

CONTACT A SELF-INSURANCE SPECIALIST

The Foundation Of Our Self-Insured Program

Claims
Administration

ZFirst Notice of Injury (FROI) Management
ZMedical-Only and Lost-Time Claims Administration
ZReserve, Litigation and Settlement Management
ZReturn-to-Work Program Administration

Medical Cost Containment

ZMedical Bill Review and Adjudication
ZNurse Case Management and Utilization Review
ZPharmacy Benefit Oversight
ZMedicare Compliance Reporting (MSP/MSA)

Regulatory Compliance

ZFederal and State Compliance Filings
ZSelf-Insurance Renewal Assistance
ZInternal Program Audits
ZOhio BWC Compliance Support

Trusted With the Details

"It has been the pleasure of Verst Logistics and Zenith Logistics to work with Sheakley UniService. We consider them an integral part of our team for over ten years and have had amazing communication and significant reduction in claims with them. Sheakley always provides input and tools to help us minimize injuries and are available whenever we need them."

— Mike H., Verst Logistics

“For nearly 25 years Sheakley has been a partner in assisting Gold Star Chili supporting our Safety, MCO & TPA program efforts.”

— Kim O., VP Human Resources, Goldstar Chili

"Working with the Sheakley team has been a consistently positive experience. Their responsiveness, expertise, and commitment to supporting our workers' compensation program have made a noticeable impact on our claims outcomes. With multiple policies under Sheakley’s management, we’ve successfully navigated complex scenarios with clarity and confidence. Their dedication, collaboration, and proactive communication truly set them apart and have made them an invaluable extension of our team."

— Shaun M., Block Communications, Inc

"I think that I would have to single out Lynn on what sets Sheakley apart .She goes above and beyond to help our program and cares about our account. Additionally, she is really knowledgeable and dependable. I really appreciate how well she collaborates with Sedgwick to ensure a good balance of our claim management."

— Melissa S., Select Medical

"Sheakley representatives are always friendly, helpful, knowledgeable and professional. I appreciate the value they provide for our school district."

— Jackie M., Conneaut Area Schools

"Sheakley has been a trusted partner for over 20 years, guiding us through cost control, cost containment and proper understanding of what we need to know."

— John T, Cornerstone Wauseon, Inc.

"The client support from the Sheakley team is truly unmatched. It's rare these days to find a partner that responds so quickly, follows through consistently, and takes the time to ensure they're doing everything possible to protect your business."

— Jessica M, Anderson Biro Staffing LLC

"Sheakley is very knowledgeable on the programs with BWC and also Rating and Retro policies! They stay on top of each opportunity available for savings and claims - A+."

— Tina A., Rollins Moving & Storage Inc

"Sheakley has been a great partner and provider of our workers comp program for over 30 years. I wouldn't trust my business to anyone else!"

— Frank C, Better Business Bureau of Canton

"I've been with Sheakley for over 10 years and have nothing but positive things to say about them. Great company that looks out for us."

— Matthew P., Polcyn Enterprises Ltd

"I have worked with Sheakley for the past 39 years, and I can confidently say it is the best company I would recommend to any business. I look forward to continuing my work here for many more years to come."

— Aydin K., Kol Group Inc.

"I have had many really positive experiences from Sheakley. They are great at answering my questions and helping with anything I need. Everyone is knowledgeable and communication is fantastic!"

— Janet K, Dean Land Company

Trusted by

OHIO BWC FORM AC-3

Check Your Eligibility for Group Rating

The AC-3 is a temporary authorization that lets Sheakley review your payroll and loss experience with the Ohio BWC, so we can tell you which group rating and group retro programs you qualify for. It takes a few minutes, carries no obligation, and expires automatically after nine months.

START THE AC-3 FORM

Take Control of Your Workers’ Comp Costs

Let Sheakley handle the programs, the claims, and the paperwork so you can focus on your business.